What everyone ought to know about choosing a mountain bike

August 31, 2013 — Leave a comment

Ask yourself these two questions when thinking, “Which mountain bike should I get?”

Choosing A Mountain BikeToying with the idea of buying a new mountain bike? Sure you could knock the dust off that old Specialized Rockhopper in the garage and have a killer time (until you remember how bad you hate grip-shifts and that petrified excuse for a seat), but maybe it’s time to cut the stretched out brake cables and move on. If you’ve been out of the mountain bike market for a half-decade or more you might be surprised to find that the new mountain bike buying decisions have evolved from:

“Should I go full-suspension and what size am I?”

to:

“Why again is there a specific bike for hopping from a dead stop onto a retaining wall? And then once I am on the retaining wall, do I really need to buy a second bike specifically designed to drop back down?”

Mountain bikes categories have divided into a mind-boggling maze of niche categories—By the time I am done writing this someone will have launched a soy-based frame for vegans, capable of making both your bike and wallet lighter, all while remaining socially conscious.

Let’s make this simple. If you are confused about all of the available options, there are a couple of fundamental questions you need to ask yourself before you start looking for a new mountain bike.

1). How much bike can I afford?

2.) Do I plan on catching any air (intentionally)?

Question 1: How much bike can I afford?

For the purposes of this article we will assume you aren’t an expert who already knows everything, but rather a humble guy or girl who is passionate about mountain biking, but has been out of the bike shopping scene for a while. Let’s also assume you are going with a full-suspension.

Prices for non-discounted bikes go something like this (the year is 2013, in the event you are reading this in the distant future):

$ Budget full-suspension bikes; $1800 and under (depressing, I know)
Look in this price range if your pocketbook requires it, or if you just want a decent bike for cruising the block, plus a handful of trips per year into the wild. For this amount it might pay to look at hardtails or a used bike with better components. Despite being on the lower-end of serious mountain bikes, products in this range are still worthy of a good time and shouldn’t be overlooked. Ultimately the bike you have is the best bike to be riding. This is also a great starting point for someone wanting to get a complete bike and swap out components for those of higher quality over time. The frames are generally exactly the same as those on the more expensive models.

$$ As much bike as you will ever need; $1800-$3000
If you’ve been riding quite a bit and want to upgrade, or are just starting out, but with a chunk of cash, this is a great price bracket to be in. You’ll end up with better components over all, and if more travel or less weight is important to you, many extra options will be available.

$$$ More bike than you will ever need; $3000+
Well, if you are looking for a bike in this category, you know who you are. And chances are you’re already an expert at justifying the rigidness of carbon fiber, the value of spec’d-out components, and the other alluring advantages these bikes offer. Mountain bikes in this price range will usually either be featherlight for cross-country racing, or long-travel bikes capable of bombing the descents, while still being capable of climbing strong when needed. If you’ve got the money, think about mountain biking daily, have owned bikes in the other two price ranges above, or if you just have an amazing accountant that thinks you can write this off; go for it!

Question 2: Do I plan on catching any air?

After identifying how much you can spend, it’s time to dive into the confusion and pick a style of bike suitable for your skill level and local terrain. It pays to have a basic understanding of these categories before you pay a visit to your local bike shop. Don’t get too hung up on which brand is better than another. Most reputable brands are very comparable with the others, so long as you are sizing up bikes built for the same purpose and in the same price range. It can be super easy to get confused at the bike shop when the staff starts talking too much about individual components and doesn’t focus on the overall type of bike you should be getting. Learn these categories below and steer your own ship.

Cross-Country
Light and less comfortable, these bikes will get you where you are headed fast. Generally they have minimal suspension in the 100mm (~4 inch) range. This will smooth out the bumps but is not ideal for jumps and drops. If you plan on racing, look sexy in Lycra, bike mainly for fitness, or like kicking your friend’s butts to the top, this is what you want. If not, move on to something more plush. These bikes are available in each of the price ranges outlined above.

Trail
The crescent wrench of the bike world; buy one of these and do it all. Perfect for larger cross-country racers or anyone who wants a do-everything bike. If you still feel confused after making it all the way through this post, this is probably the best choice for you. These are the sweet spot as far as value goes. With suspension lengths averaging around 120-130mm (~5 inches) of travel and available in any of the price ranges mentioned above, it is hard to go wrong in this category. These bikes will launch off reasonably sized drops if you are a smooth rider, and usually offer a nice balance of speed and comfort. I’d lean towards the middle price range mentioned above and get the best suspension components for your dollar.

All-Mountain
Want a fully capable bike that crushes the descents, is capable of big air, and can still hold its own on the uphills? This is what you are looking for. In general, these bikes fall into the latter two of the price categories above and probably lean more towards the highest tier if you want a quality shock and fork. These bikes are forgiving and handle obstacles similar to a downhill specific bike, but are also fully prepared to tackle a long enduro ride through rolling hills. Where I live in Northern Utah most of our rides are out-and-backs (as opposed to loops or shuttles) and provide a great proving ground for bikes that claim this level of versatility. I’ve personally spent a lot of time riding a Santa Cruz Nomad and I’ve never complained about riding it uphill for hours, while looking forward to the reward of a killer descent on the way back. All-Mountain bikes generally have travel lengths around 160mm (~6 inches) and have a slack, or relaxed, frame geometry, making them the most comfortable, rideable bikes in my opinion. I wouldn’t recommend this category to those on a tight budget or those who are not interested in being aggressive on the downhill and spending some time airborne over two wheels.

Downhill
Designed to cover more mountain trail while powered by gravity than by strenuous pedaling. I’ve spent some time at Whistler, BC on a downhill bike and was amazed at how smoothly the bike could cancel out my poor jumping technique. I am not an expert in this category, but I know not to recommend these to anyone looking to pedal up hills or long distances. They generally live around 200mm (~8 inches) of travel and are squishy beasts than can tame a wild mountain. While this is undoubtedly one of the most fun categories of bikes, they are very specific to a certain type of riding and if you don’t have a local scene, steer clear. Downhill bikes are available in all of the price categories previously covered.

Specialty
After trying so hard to keep things simple it wouldn’t be fair for me to drag you through the endless options and variations on the bikes above. Let’s just say that there are fat bikes, dirt jumpers, cyclocross, and a bunch of niche bikes. Avoid all of these unless you already know what you are doing and aren’t looking for a one-bike-does-it-all mountain bike.

Make these two decisions before venturing out and there is a great chance you’ll find the perfect bike. I have intentionally not mentioned specific brands and models, but have rather focused on two decisions you should make first (the Specialized bike pics were chosen only because of convenience). Once you have an idea of your budget and bike style, it might be helpful to start looking through the reviews at www.mtbr.com to help you drill down further. Get a bike and have fun.

SUBSCRIBE!

No Comments

Be the first to start the conversation.

Leave a Reply

*

Text formatting is available via select HTML.

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>